Is MUSHing Dead?

May 18, 2011 at 3:38 am (Admin Posts) (, )

Lots of people believe that MUSHing is a dying art form.  They believe we’ve been driven out by MMORPGs.  I don’t really believe it though.  New MUDs and MUSHes are still cropping up.  There are still plenty of people who will pour hours into this hobby, who want an in-depth RP experience that can’t be duplicated by a bunch of people who can’t spell or stay in character very well.  However, something did happen in the MUSH community.

We all got older.

We started careers.  Had kids.  Got a lot more tired.  We lost a lot of our energy.  We can’t stay up from 6 pm till 4 am anymore, RPing scenes.  And the kids who can still do that are all starting MU*s in themes we maybe can’t really get behind, because they appeal to younger audiences.

Yet many MUSH conventions and Ways of Doing Things still run on the assumption that we are all still 18 years old, living at university or with our parents, and in possession of biological clocks that allow us to be around pretty much…well.  Always.  For example, take our perception of “an active MUSH player.”  People on MU*s get status if they are “really active.”  If they attend all the events.  Are always out and about RPing.  We give less weight to people who RP one or two scenes a week.  They are not active.  They aren’t in step, in the loop, being movers and shakers…and they feel that.

What if we valued those people more?  What if, in fact, we slowed the pace of our MU*s a bit so that those sorts of people could have fun too?

Take scheduling plot scenes.  We have gotten into a habit of wanting or needing specific people for our plot scenes.  Sometimes that’s not really avoidable.  Sometimes, though, it might be better if we just did impromptu shout outs.  Let whomever just show up.  And to design plots that makes that possible.

Take our plots.  Plots that take a week are sometimes more feasible for the older crowd than long, drawn out, involved tiny plots with lots and lots and LOTS of details.

Take consent.  The old way was to try to extrapolate ICC from one scene out to its bitter end when negotiating events.  Maybe we just need to say that consent lasts for a single scene, as the Road to Amber MUSH did.  If you want to do more to the character you have to negotiate a new scene.  That way, you can just come online and relax instead of worrying and waiting and fretting about whether your character is going to be playable.  After all, you’re running on a limited amount of time and energy.  The old way was ICC=ICA because there were a lot of idiots running around.  We idiots have grown up.  The new way should maybe be: you know what, we both have 4 hours tonight. How can we make 4 hours really fun?

I think a lot of the time players come onto the game with specific fantasies about how they’d like to interact with that world, and if they can’t get those fantasies met they tend to drift on until they find a place that clicks better for them.  Or, if they feel hostility from the staff and players because they can’t be around more than two or three times a week–they move on.   Maybe we can find better ways to help players sketch out the scenes they saw in their head when they said, “Let’s try playing here.”  Maybe we can find ways to be more tolerant of people’s schedules and lives.  Maybe we can rethink what the MUSH hobby means.

I’m not saying my solutions are the best ones, necessarily.  Anyone who starts tilting their game towards that older demographic is actually breaking new ground.  MUSHing won’t die if we let it evolve with us.  It will die, however, if that new ground does not get broken.



  1. Mr. Wiggles said,

    Mushes seem to be dying. Some of it, is the culture of mu*ing, the larger aspect, I think, is that we’re far to insular.

    We are in indirect competition, with browser games and MMO. This isn’t because potencial mu*s players would rather play an MMO, or any number of the browser games, its because they dont know we exist.

    Outside of being highlighted in a New York Time Article, (strangely enough, because of Jim Butcher, who highlights the Ambermush for honing his story telling and writing skills,) we dont have exposure. That New York Time Article, didnt give a link to mudconnect or anything.

    We need to expose ourselves. We need to be more vocal.

    I’m starting to. I’m starting by writing to RPG podcast, if they’re willing to do a segment on Mu*s. So far, I’ve sent out one, and currently listening to other podcasts to see if they’re an appropriate avenue.

    The average mu* user, could do a lot, just by simply talking about mu*s on the forum they happen to lurk out. If someone is talking about MMO, drop a post or two about Mu*’s.

    • ladyrane said,

      I think you’re probably right–not enough fresh blood, and too many burnt out staffers of the old guard who don’t have a lot of patience anymore. It’s also a “thinking person’s” game. The “lowest common denominator” mentality does not apply there.

  2. Damian said,

    This is very much where I am at the moment. In my past life, I was an active MUSHer. I would be online and active on the two or three MU*s I had committed to from about 22:00 – 04:00 several nights a week. I loved it.

    Now, though, I am in a serious relationship, working and have a small child. I can’t commit to more than a couple of hours a week. I miss the ability to interact meaningfully with a good quality MU*, but I am not going to alter my RL situation to crowbar that back in…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: